All posts
Design / Studio

Fewer Routes, Better Decisions: How Many Design Concepts a Client Should See

ZKO blog tile: Design

There is a common belief in design that more options mean better value. A client paying for a new identity or campaign should see six, eight, a dozen concepts. In our experience the opposite is true. Past three, every extra route makes the decision harder and the final work weaker.

The problem with many concepts is that they cannot all be good. Producing eight serious routes takes far more time than producing three, so the extra five are usually thinner. And clients have an uncanny habit of picking the weakest one, often because it is the safest, or asking to combine elements of four different routes into one.

So for identity, campaign and key visual work, we usually present two or three routes. Each one has to be genuinely different, not three colour variations of the same idea. One might be the expected answer done very well. Another might push the brief somewhere bolder. A third, when there is one, might take a completely different starting point, such as type-led instead of symbol-led.

Each route comes with its reasoning. We show where it came from, what problem in the brief it answers, and how it would work in real use: on a website header, a social post, an exhibition stand, a van, or a 3D product shot. Seeing a logo on a mock exhibition wall or animated in a short motion test tells a client far more than seeing it on a white slide.

We also say which route we would choose and why. Some studios avoid this in case they influence the client. We think that is the job. A client hires a studio for judgement, and hiding it behind a neutral presentation leaves them to guess.

When the client chooses, the follow-up is about refining one direction, not merging three. If a client loves the typeface from route one and the colour from route two, we talk about why, and often the answer is a better version of one route rather than a combination of both.

The same thinking applies beyond branding. For a 3D render, we agree one camera and a couple of lighting moods rather than ten angles. For a website, we design one home page properly instead of three half-built ones.

Fewer routes means more depth in each, clearer feedback, and fewer rounds of revisions. Clients get to a decision faster, and the final work is better argued. It feels less generous on the day, and it is more generous by the end of the project.